Tutto il Giorno: Upscale Italian Dining Experience in Sag Harbor

The place was still very busy at 10pm. The food was delicious and the staff were super friendly. The atmosphere was wonderful. I would give 5 stars except that it was expensive and portion size small.

I was a bit disappointed by the food and systems here. The bread was rock hard and almost impossible to break or chew. My risotto special was flavorless. On the plus side, my table companions liked their entrees. The runners weren't properly trained--we had to ask for silverware and water several times. Our waiter seemed super-stressed, but he rallied and was wonderful ultimately. We ended up really appreciating him.

Someone recommended this place to us, and it was definitely worth a visit! I would recommend getting a reservation unless you go early. The food was soul satisfying! I wouldn’t call it like omg this is excellent, and you can’t find this anywhere, you can, but to find a really good Italian place is tough. In the area, this is definitely one of the best Italian places. Everything we ordered was on point and how we expected it to be.

We celebrated our 30th Wedding Anniversary and between the staff and server Dillon they made it a special and memorable experience! The chef even came out to congratulate us! Thank you all!

A great experience, in one of the best Italian restaurants on LI. Niccollo took care of us. He was great. Bane (bread and olive oil) and the salad was delicious and fresh. The salad was pricey but we split it so that helped. The rigatoni was out of this world. Spicy for me with meats, pink sauce and peas. Rigatoni and eggplant for her, salty and el dente. Niccollo even offered some extra bread (it isn't free, it's a menu item). We declined because we eat too much but that was very nice to offer and it went a long way with us! We were lucky enough to get an outside table next to a heat fire so it was warm. No reservations but we timed it right. The host was a David from Schitts Creek lookalike. He squeezed us in. The place is gorgeous and in the entryway of Sag Harbor town. I recommend the restaurant, just bring your wallet. Go see Niccollo! Tell em Barsnobs sent ya!

Went there yesterday! A solid restaurant pick. Pasta was delicious and fish was nice if a bit expensive. Our waiters were charismatic and attentive. Tiramisu was a great wnd to the meal, too.

Had the most incredible meal at Tutto il Giorno tonight! Thank you to our knowledgeable and attentive waitress Barbara for incredible service and for her delicious suggestions. We’ve had a hard time finding food worth the price tag here and this place certainly does just that! The burrata, spaghetti, rigatoni, and dessert options were amazing.

What an utterly unforgettable Valentine’s Day at Tutto! From the very first moment, the evening felt like something out of a romance film. The food was exquisite — every bite a love letter to flavor. The cocktails? Pure artistry in a glass. And the ambiance struck that perfect balance between intimate and electric, wrapping the whole room in a warm, golden glow. But above all, there’s Sam. He isn’t just part of the experience — he is the experience. The undeniable heart and soul of the room, effortlessly orchestrating the night with charm, warmth, and a presence that makes everyone feel like the most important guest in the world. If Tutto is a stage, Sam is the star. Absolute perfection from start to finish.